Skip to content

Investor Validation Interview Guide v0.1

Swiss VC Portfolio Transparency Needs Assessment

🎯 Interview Objectives

Primary Goals:

  • Validate investor pain points around portfolio marketing transparency
  • Test willingness to fund/mandate integrated marketing services
  • Understand decision-making process for operational portfolio tools
  • Assess value perception of standardized marketing measurement

Success Criteria:

  • Confirm genuine interest in portfolio transparency solutions
  • Validate pricing assumptions for investor-sponsored services
  • Identify specific requirements for pilot program participation
  • Establish next steps for potential partnership

📋 Pre-Interview Preparation

Research Target Investor (30 minutes):

Background Research:
✓ Investment thesis and focus areas (stage, sector, geography)
✓ Portfolio size and composition (number of companies, stages)
✓ Recent investments and press releases
✓ Partner backgrounds and operational involvement philosophy
✓ Competitive positioning vs. other Swiss VCs

Key Information Sources:
• VC website and portfolio page
• LinkedIn profiles of key partners
• Crunchbase investment history
• Swiss startup ecosystem reports
• News articles and interviews

Prepare Interview Materials:

Physical Materials:
✓ One-page company overview (printed)
✓ Investor value proposition summary
✓ Sample portfolio transparency dashboard mockup
✓ Business cards and contact information

Digital Materials:
✓ 5-minute product demo video (ready to play)
✓ Portfolio ROI calculator (simple Excel/Google Sheets)
✓ Competitive analysis showing current alternatives
✓ Pilot program proposal template

🗣️ Interview Structure (45-60 minutes)

Opening (5 minutes) - Relationship Building

Warm-Up & Context Setting: 

"Thank you for taking the time to meet with me. I'm [Name], building [Company] to solve 
portfolio marketing transparency challenges for Swiss VCs.

Before we dive in, could you tell me a bit about your role at [VC Firm] and how you 
think about operational support for your portfolio companies?"

Follow-up prompts:
• "How hands-on is your firm with portfolio company operations?"
• "What types of value-add services do you currently provide?"
• "How do you differentiate from other Swiss VCs in terms of operational support?"

Problem Discovery (15 minutes) - Validate Pain Points

Current Portfolio Management: 

"I'd love to understand how you currently assess marketing effectiveness across 
your portfolio companies..."

Key Questions:
1. "How do you currently track marketing performance across your portfolio?"
   - Follow-up: "What data do you receive from portfolio companies?"
   - Follow-up: "How consistent is this reporting across companies?"

2. "What challenges do you face in understanding marketing ROI for your investments?"
   - Follow-up: "How do you compare marketing effectiveness between portfolio companies?"
   - Follow-up: "What would better visibility into marketing performance enable for you?"

3. "How important is marketing transparency for your LP reporting and fund performance?"
   - Follow-up: "Do your LPs ask about operational metrics beyond financial performance?"
   - Follow-up: "How does operational excellence factor into your fund differentiation?"

4. "When you're evaluating new investments, how do you assess a startup's marketing capabilities?"
   - Follow-up: "What marketing red flags concern you during due diligence?"
   - Follow-up: "How often do marketing execution issues affect portfolio company performance?"

Current Solutions Assessment: 

5. "What tools or services do your portfolio companies currently use for marketing?"
   - Follow-up: "Are you satisfied with the consistency and quality of these solutions?"
   - Follow-up: "Do you recommend specific marketing vendors to portfolio companies?"

6. "How do you currently help portfolio companies with marketing challenges?"
   - Follow-up: "Do you have in-house marketing expertise or external partnerships?"
   - Follow-up: "What marketing support would you like to provide but currently can't?"

Solution Validation (15 minutes) - Test Value Proposition

Concept Introduction: 

"Based on what you've shared, I'd like to show you a concept we're developing that 
addresses some of these challenges..."

[Present 1-2 slides or demo showing]:
• Integrated execution + transparency model
• Portfolio-wide standardized reporting
• Swiss quality marketing with AI coordination

Value Proposition Testing: 

7. "How valuable would it be to have standardized marketing execution and reporting 
   across your entire portfolio?"
   - Follow-up: "What specific insights would be most valuable for portfolio management?"
   - Follow-up: "How would this affect your ability to help companies improve performance?"

8. "What would it mean for your fund if you could demonstrate operational excellence 
   in marketing to your LPs?"
   - Follow-up: "How would this differentiate you from other Swiss VCs?"
   - Follow-up: "Would this influence your ability to raise future funds?"

9. "If you could ensure all your portfolio companies had professional marketing 
   infrastructure from day one, how would that impact their success?"
   - Follow-up: "What percentage of your companies struggle with marketing execution?"
   - Follow-up: "How often do marketing issues delay or derail growth plans?"

Business Model Validation (10 minutes) - Test Willingness to Pay

Investment and Mandate Willingness: 

10. "Would you consider funding marketing transparency tools as part of your 
    investment in portfolio companies?"
    - Follow-up: "How would you structure this - as part of the funding round or separate?"
    - Follow-up: "What budget range would be appropriate for portfolio-wide transparency?"

11. "Would you be willing to mandate the use of standardized marketing tools 
    across your portfolio for transparency purposes?"
    - Follow-up: "How do you typically introduce operational requirements to portfolio companies?"
    - Follow-up: "What resistance would you expect and how would you handle it?"

12. "If such a solution existed today, what would it need to cost to be compelling 
    for your fund?"
    - Follow-up: "How do you typically budget for portfolio operational support?"
    - Follow-up: "Would you pay per company or prefer a fund-level pricing model?"

Implementation Considerations: 

13. "What would be your requirements for implementing a portfolio-wide marketing solution?"
    - Follow-up: "How important is Swiss-based talent vs. international alternatives?"
    - Follow-up: "What integration challenges would you anticipate?"

14. "How would you measure success for such a portfolio-wide implementation?"
    - Follow-up: "What metrics would convince you to expand beyond a pilot?"
    - Follow-up: "How long would you need to see results before making a long-term commitment?"

Partnership Exploration (10 minutes) - Assess Pilot Interest

Pilot Program Interest: 

15. "Would you be interested in piloting this approach with 2-3 of your portfolio companies?"
    - Follow-up: "Which companies would be good candidates for a pilot?"
    - Follow-up: "What would need to be true for you to move forward with a pilot?"

16. "What concerns would you have about implementing this with your portfolio companies?"
    - Follow-up: "How would you introduce this to founders in your portfolio?"
    - Follow-up: "What guarantees or protections would you need?"

17. "If we could demonstrate clear ROI with a pilot, how quickly could you make a 
    decision about broader implementation?"
    - Follow-up: "Who else would be involved in that decision-making process?"
    - Follow-up: "What would the timeline look like for portfolio-wide rollout?"

Closing & Next Steps (5 minutes)

Wrap-Up: 

18. "What other investors in the Swiss ecosystem do you think would be interested 
    in this type of solution?"
    - Follow-up: "Would you be willing to provide introductions if our pilot is successful?"

19. "What additional information would you need to move forward with a pilot discussion?"
    - Follow-up: "What timeline works for your decision-making process?"

20. "Any final thoughts or concerns about this concept that we haven't discussed?"

Next Steps Confirmation: 

"Based on our conversation, it sounds like [summarize key interests and concerns].

The logical next step would be [specific action - pilot proposal, additional information, etc.].

I'll follow up with [specific deliverables] by [specific date]. Does that timeline work for you?"

📝 Interview Documentation Template

Investor Profile:

Company: [VC Firm Name]
Interviewer: [Partner/Principal Name and Title]
Date: [Interview Date]
Duration: [Actual Length]
Location: [Office/Video Call]

Fund Details:
• Fund size and investment stage focus
• Portfolio size (number of companies)
• Typical check size and investment criteria
• Operational involvement philosophy

Key Insights Captured:

PAIN POINTS VALIDATED:
□ Portfolio marketing transparency gaps
□ Inconsistent reporting across companies
□ Difficulty comparing performance between investments
□ LP reporting and differentiation challenges
□ Marketing execution problems affecting portfolio performance

SOLUTION INTEREST:
□ Integrated execution + transparency model appeal
□ Standardized portfolio reporting value
□ Swiss quality premium acceptance
□ AI coordination concept understanding

BUSINESS MODEL VALIDATION:
□ Willingness to fund transparency tools
□ Portfolio mandate authority and willingness
□ Budget range and pricing model preferences
□ Implementation timeline and process requirements

PILOT PROGRAM POTENTIAL:
□ Interest level (High/Medium/Low)
□ Specific portfolio companies mentioned
□ Requirements and concerns expressed
□ Decision-making process and timeline

Specific Quotes to Capture:

Problem Validation:
"[Quote about current portfolio transparency challenges]"

Value Proposition:
"[Quote about integrated solution appeal]"

Pricing/Investment:
"[Quote about willingness to fund or budget considerations]"

Concerns/Objections:
"[Quote about specific concerns or implementation challenges]"

Next Steps:
"[Quote about pilot interest or requirements]"

Action Items & Follow-Up:

COMMITMENTS MADE:
□ [Specific information to provide]
□ [Materials to send]
□ [Demonstrations to arrange]
□ [Timeline for follow-up]

REQUESTS FOR US:
□ [Additional research needed]
□ [Product development priorities]
□ [Business model adjustments]
□ [Partnership structure considerations]

NEXT MEETING:
□ Date/Time: [If scheduled]
□ Agenda: [Topics to cover]
□ Attendees: [Who should be included]
□ Materials: [What to prepare]

🎯 Question Adaptation Guide

For Different VC Types:

Early-Stage Focused VCs: - Emphasize helping companies build professional marketing from day one - Focus on preventing common early-stage marketing mistakes - Highlight investor reporting benefits for Series A fundraising

Growth-Stage VCs: - Focus on scaling marketing operations and efficiency - Emphasize portfolio benchmarking and best practice sharing - Highlight operational due diligence and post-investment monitoring

Sector-Specific VCs (e.g., Tech, B2B): - Tailor examples to their sector expertise - Reference specific marketing challenges in their focus areas - Highlight how standardized approach works across different business models

For Different Seniority Levels:

Managing Partners/Senior Partners: - Focus on fund differentiation and LP value creation - Emphasize competitive advantage and market positioning - Discuss portfolio-wide strategy and implementation

Principals/Associates: - Focus on operational efficiency and portfolio support - Emphasize day-to-day benefits for portfolio management - Discuss specific implementation challenges and solutions

⚠️ Common Interview Pitfalls to Avoid

Don't Lead the Witness:

❌ "Wouldn't it be valuable to have portfolio transparency?" ✅ "How do you currently assess marketing performance across your portfolio?"

Don't Oversell Early:

❌ Start with product demo and features ✅ Start with understanding their current challenges

Don't Ignore Objections:

❌ Dismiss concerns or push past resistance ✅ Explore concerns deeply and understand root causes

Don't Rush to Close:

❌ "So are you ready to do a pilot?" ✅ "What would need to be true for a pilot to make sense?"

Don't Forget to Listen:

❌ Talk 80% of the time ✅ Listen 70% of the time, talk 30%

📊 Success Metrics for Validation Interviews

Immediate Success Indicators:

High Interest:
□ Interview runs longer than scheduled time
□ Detailed questions about implementation and pricing
□ Requests for product demonstration or additional materials
□ Mentions specific portfolio companies for potential pilot
□ Offers to provide introductions to other investors

Medium Interest:
□ Acknowledges problem but uncertain about solution fit
□ General interest but no specific next steps defined
□ Requests more information before making decisions
□ Concerned about implementation challenges or cost

Low Interest:
□ Short interview with surface-level engagement
□ Doesn't see portfolio transparency as priority
□ Satisfied with current solutions
□ No follow-up interest or next steps

Validation Targets Across Interviews:

Problem Validation: >70% confirm significant portfolio transparency challenges
Solution Fit: >50% express interest in integrated execution + transparency model
Pricing Acceptance: >40% indicate willingness to fund at projected price points
Pilot Interest: >30% express willingness to participate in pilot program

📅 Post-Interview Process

Immediate Follow-Up (Same Day):

□ Complete documentation template while details are fresh
□ Identify key insights and quotes for business model validation
□ Note any product/business model adjustments suggested
□ Schedule follow-up actions and timeline

24-Hour Follow-Up:

□ Send thank you email with conversation summary
□ Provide any materials requested during interview
□ Confirm next steps and timeline discussed
□ Update investor CRM with interview outcomes

Weekly Analysis:

□ Review patterns across multiple investor interviews
□ Identify common pain points and solution requirements
□ Adjust interview guide based on learnings
□ Prioritize product development based on feedback
□ Refine business model and pricing based on input

Interview Guide Status: v0.1 - Initial Framework for Swiss VC Validation Next Update: Refinement based on actual interview learnings and feedback patterns

Research & Analysis:

Business Principles:

  • [[Investor_Led_Sales_Channel|Investor-Led Sales Channel Strategy]]

Strategic Planning:

  • [[Pre-Seed_Validation_Roadmap_v0_2|Pre-Seed Validation Roadmap v0.2]]
  • [[Critical_Open_Questions_v0.1|Critical Open Questions v0.1]]